Why rankings fall after a new site goes live
Google ranks pages, not websites. Each page you rank for sits at an address, and other sites link to that address. Launch a new site with a different structure and those addresses start returning 'page not found'. The links pointing at them stop counting, and the pages Google had learned to trust disappear from its index.
The second cause is content. If the page that ranked for 'boiler repair Birmingham' is replaced by a shorter, prettier page that no longer says it, the ranking goes with the words.
The checklist
Before anything goes live:
- Export every address on the old site — from its sitemap, Google Search Console and a crawl — not just the ones in the menu.
- Map each old address to its new one. Where a page no longer exists, send it to the closest equivalent, never just to the homepage.
- Set up permanent (301) redirects for every address that changes.
- Keep the titles, headings and copy that the ranking pages already had, and improve them rather than starting again.
- Carry over structured data, image alt text and internal links.
- Submit the new sitemap in Search Console on launch day, then watch its coverage and 404 reports for the following weeks.
How it went for Ofena
When we rebuilt Ofena's website on Cloudflare in August 2026, we started on the 16th and it was live on the 20th — with the quote builder, the admin area and every old address still working. Its images went from 78.5 MB to 15.4 MB in the process, so the new site was quicker than the one it replaced as well.
A rebuild is a chance to rank better
Done carefully, a new site should gain ground: faster pages, cleaner markup and better content are all things search engines reward. The redirects just make sure you keep what you had while you get there.